The moral issue with human cloning

But a begotten child comes into the world just as its parents once did, and is therefore their equal in dignity and humanity.

The Legal and Ethical Issues of Cloning That Make it Controversial

Scientific research may be used for the good of man in a crisis. Also people began to realize the implications on our society, if somatic cell nuclear tranfer became a widespread process, cloning could begin to undermine many of our social values, such as children and people becomming more like objects rather than individual beings.

The Ethics of Human Cloning

We are already liable to regard children largely as vehicles for our own fulfillment and ambitions. The technique used to make the clone of the sheep is called somatic cell nuclear transfer. To this point, parents have the right and the power to decide whether to have a child.

Why do scientists want to clone human beings? We will now attempt to deepen that analysis, and begin with the salient fact that a child is not made, but begotten. Procreation can, of course, be assisted by human ingenuity as with IVF.

The key ethical issue with therapeutic cloning is the moral status of the cloned embryo, which is created solely for destruction. Creating exact copies or cloning human beings has always fired the human imagination. The problem has to do with the control of the entire genotype and the production of children to selected specifications.

But in cloning experiments to produce children, researchers would be transforming a sexual system into an asexual one, a change that requires major and "unnatural" reprogramming of donor DNA if there is to be any chance of success.

And then, of course, IVF was accomplished. While some people contend that cloning-to-produce-children would not take us much further down a path we have already been traveling, we would emphasize that the precedent of treating children as projects cuts two ways in the moral argument.

Why does this matter? Problems of Exploitation of Women and Just Distribution of Risk Cloning-to-produce-children may also lead to the exploitation of women who would be called upon to donate oocytes. Trans-genetic manipulation, where genetic material from one species is artificially inserted into another species, if applied to humans, would lead to transfer of diseases from other species.

The Ethical, Social & Legal Issues of Cloning Animals & Humans

In regards to the cloning of whole organisms, however, the benefits are largely found in increasing nutrition derived from food. It invites us to accept limits to our control over the next generation. The process involves introducing the nuclear material of a human somatic cell donor into an oocyte egg cell whose own nucleus has been removed or inactivated, and then stimulating this new entity to begin dividing and growing, yielding a cloned human embryo.

A society that clones human beings thinks about human beings and especially children differently than does a society that refuses to do so.

Thus, anticipating the possibility of a perfected and usable technology, it is important to delineate the case against the practice itself. In England, for example, the House of Lords recently voted to 92 in favor of promoting experiments which will attempt to clone human beings — even though a conglomerate of religious leaders Roman Catholics, Protestants, Jews, Muslims, and Sikhs petitioned the politicians to pause and study the ethical issues involved in such an ambitious enterprise.

It is an emblem of independence and individuality. Yet, although cloning does not in itself point to public policies by which the state would become involved in directing the development of the human gene pool, this might happen in illiberal regimes, like China, where the government already regulates procreation.

It copncluded that "some religious thinkers argue that the use of somatic cell nuclear transfer cloning is intrinsicly immoral and can never be morrally justified. Whether it be to actually clone a human to raise as a child, or for medical purposes, I do not think that cloning should be allowed to take place.

Any onslaught against a fellow human being, regardless of his stage of development, is ultimately against God. Lacking such understanding, no one should take action so drastic as the cloning of a human child.

Cloned children would thus be the first human beings whose entire genetic makeup is selected in advance. But a different frame of reference is needed to evaluate the human meaning of innovations that may affect the lives and humanity of everyone, vulnerable or not.

They are neither enabling nor restoring a natural process, and the alterations involved are such that success in one species cannot be presumed to predict success in another.

How does therapeutic cloning differ from reproductive cloning? On the other hand, Dr. To be sure, there are differing views about how to define "health. It therefore appears to us that, given the dangers involved and the relatively limited goods to be gained from cloning-to-produce-children, conducting experiments in an effort to make cloning-to-produce-children safer would itself be an unacceptable violation of the norms of the ethics of research.

Even pro-choice advocates and others who hold liberal and progressive political views find sufficient ethical concerns for opposing the procedure. The primary moral objection to cloning-for-research is the same as for all embryo-destructive research—it creates human life solely for the purpose of destroying it; using a human embryo merely as a means to an end e.“Cloning” has been a volatile topic in the news of late.

In England, for example, the House of Lords recently voted to 92 in favor of promoting experiments which will attempt to clone human beings – even though a conglomerate of religious leaders (Roman Catholics, Protestants, Jews, Muslims, and Sikhs) petitioned the politicians to pause and study the ethical issues.

Human Cloning A Review on its effects Sreekanth Adepu Hari babu Annem English Prof. Cynthia Day November 24, | | |Over the past 8 years since the development of first human clone human cloning is a controversial issue.

Human Cloning: Summary from Source: National BioEthics Advisory Commission: Cloning Human Beings The idea of cloning human beings used to only be found in science fiction novels.

After the cloning of the sheep, Dolly, there came the possibility of making it a reality. Many people realised the moral issue concerning the children.

Ethics of cloning

Free Essay: Human Cloning is not a Moral Issue There has been an onslaught of protests and people lobbying for a ban on human cloning ever since Dolly the.

Cloning suggests the possibility of growing or cultivating human beings in the future. The Ethical Implications of Human Cloning Department of Government,Harvard University, Cambridge Street,Cambridge,MA, the heart of the ethical moral problem with reproductive cloning lies not in its asexual character,but in its assault on the understanding of children as.

The moral issue with human cloning
Rated 3/5 based on 94 review